Return to About Mormons home

Accusatory Questions

I just wanted to ask about the story of Coriantumr smiting off the head of Shiz (Ether 15:31).  Is it really possible for a man to rise and struggle after having his head cut off?  I find this passage a bit puzzling?   Could you please explain?

by Elder George Reynolds

Those who are fond of finding fault with the Book of Mormon, and they are many, are disposed to ridicule some of the incidents therein given, connected with the death of Shiz, the rival of Coriantumr for the supreme rulership of the Jaredite race during the last days of that degenerate people. The war, which at its commencement found the Jaredites a nation many million strong, was carried on with such relentless ferocity, that, at its close, the two contending monarchs, Shiz and Coriantumr, alone remained. Then followed the death of Shiz. The story of his last moments is thus told by Moroni, in his abridgment of the writings of the Prophet Ether:

And it came to pass that when they had all fallen by the sword, save it were Coriantumr and Shiz behold Shiz had fainted with loss of blood.

And it came. to pass that when Coriantumr had leaned upon his sword, that he rested a little, he smote off the head of

And it came to pass that after he had smote off the head of Shiz that Shiz raised upon his hands and fell; and after he had struggled for breath he died.

There is nothing so wonderfully strange about this, that it should excite contempt or even ridicule. Recorded instances are. numerous of men who were suddenly decapitated, showing signs of vitality and will power as did Shiz, for several seconds after their heads were cut off. This is more especially the case when they

are intensely wrought up, as be was, in the hatreds and excitements of actual combat One instance which we have noticed is referred to in the Popular Science Monthly, 1). 1 16 for June, 1892. The writer, Geo. L. Kilmer, says:

On the 17th if June, (1864?) in the charge of the Ninth Corps on the Confederate works east of Petersburg, a sargeant of the Fifty-Seventh Massachusetts leaped upon the parapet, and with his cap in his left hand and his musket in his right, stood cheering and gesturing with his arms to incite his comrades to come on. Suddenly a shell took off his head as completely as a knife could have done, but the tall form continued erect for some seconds, the arms still waving frantically but with ever-lessening sweep and power, until the forces of the body collapsed, when the headless trunk toppled over to the ground.

Again, Hawthorne relates that a sea captain once told him of an incident which was said to have occurred during the action between the Constitution and the Macedonia which was fought during the war of 1812, between Great Britain and the United States. The captain was, at tile time, powder-monkey aboard the Coastitution, and saw a cannon shot come through the ship's side. A seaman's head was struck off, probably by a splinter, for it was done, he said, a.; clean as by a razor, without bruising the head or body. The unfortunate man, at the time of the Occurrence, was walking pretty briskly, and the captain affirmed that he kept walking onward at the same pace, with two jets of blood gushing from his headless trunk, till, after going about twenty feet without a head, he sank down at once with his legs under him.

A telegram received from South Africa, on February 1st, of the present year says:

A curious incident is related of the fighting at Spion Kop [between the British and the Boers] on January 24. One of the soldiers of the English Lancaster Regiment while firing as lie lay face downward, had his head taken clean off by a shell. To the amazement of his comrades, the headless body quietly rose, stood upright a few seconds and then fell.

This last example is almost a perfect parallel to what is related of Shiz. And so, if necessary, instances could be multiplied where nien have shown for a few moments vitality equal to that attributed to Shiz by the sacred historian; when they, like him, had, by the fortunes of war, been deprived of their heads.

(See The Book of Mormon home page; Response to Criticism home page; Accusatory Questions home page)

Improvement Era, Vol. 3, 1900: 588-589
Copyright by The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints

All About Mormons